Which preposition to use with benumbed

with Occurrences 15%

they stood out to sea, and, without approaching any land, sailed forward, till, on the night following, the 3rd of June, being then in the latitude of thirty-eight degrees, they were suddenly benumbed with such cold blasts, that they were scarcely able to handle the ropes.

to Occurrences 4%

The chill of the storm was so benumbing to muscles and senses that further flying could only result in stupor, then death.

in Occurrences 3%

She paid no heed to Mrs. Atterbury, to Olympia, kneeling beside herall her heart, all her senses benumbed in the agony of the cruel blow.

without Occurrences 1%

The poor maiden wandered on, and on, and on, until she came upon the banks of a dart, cold river; wild and lost amid tempest and storm, she wandered down its banks, until, in despair, chilled and benumbed without heart or hope, she laid her down to die, and the pure snow covered her.

on Occurrences 1%

Some, undoubtedly, perish in storms, and I have found thousands lying dead or benumbed on the surface of the glaciers, to which they had perhaps been attracted by the white glare, taking them for beds of bloom.

at Occurrences 1%

The feet grow benumbed at last, powerless to hold on any longer, and the lynx tumbles off into the wolves' jaws; or else, knowing the danger, he leaps for the nearest wolf and dies fighting.

as Occurrences 1%

Many of us when we have lost a sustaining button, have we not felt as ridiculously helpless and wit-benumbed as the smart speller?

Which preposition to use with  benumbed