Which preposition to use with caressings

of Occurrences 4%

Peggy it proved to be; and after the weeping, and laughing, and caressing of the meeting were a little abated, the following explanation was made by Peters, who spoke the language of his wife with a good deal of facility, and who acted as interpreter.

as Occurrences 4%

The horse then went straight to Angelica in a way as caressing as a dog; for he remembered how she fed him in Albracca at the time when she was in love with his ungracious master: and the beauty recollected Bayardo with equal pleasure, for she had need of him.

in Occurrences 2%

On the other hand Madame Kalitine became still more caressing in her behavior towards her guest.

with Occurrences 2%

She danced, you know, with a serious face; she danced with a serious dignity, and yet she was smiling at me and caressing mesmiling and caressing with her eyes.

to Occurrences 2%

There were none of those signs in the animal world outside, of premature stir and cheerful awaking, that in other lands help the illusion that winter lies behind, but there was that even more stimulating sweet air abroad, that subtle mixture of sun and yielding frost, that softened wind that comes blowing across the snow, still keen to the cheek, but subtly reviving to the sensitive nostril, and caressing to the eyes.

on Occurrences 1%

For presently it had come on to raina thick, dank rain, which wetted through all covering, yet fell soft as caressing on the skin.

from Occurrences 1%

A pat and a rub around the ears from the man, and a more prolonged caressing from the woman, and he was away down the trail in front of them, gliding effortlessly over the ground in true wolf fashion.

Which preposition to use with  caressings