Which preposition to use with cumulative

for Occurrences 2%

The New York times index; annual cumulative for 1946.

as Occurrences 1%

And yet we must not rely too much even upon evidence so strong and so cumulative as this.

in Occurrences 1%

French influence was cumulative in changing the cumbersome style of Milton's prose to the polished, neatly-turned sentences of Addison.

to Occurrences 1%

I have always been of opinion that this distress and suffering must be cumulative to a degree which few people have ever foreseen, because your means of meeting the difficulty will diminish just in proportion as the difficulty will increase.

Which preposition to use with  cumulative