Which preposition to use with earnshaw

for Occurrences 1%

The frustrated passion of Catherine Earnshaw for Heathcliff, and of Heathcliff for Catherine, hardly knows itself from hate; they pay each other back torture for torture, and pang for hopeless pang.

from Occurrences 1%

Mr. Heathcliff, who grew more and more disinclined to society, almost banished Earnshaw from his apartment, and was tired of seeing Catherinethat was the reason why I was sent forand the two young people were thrown perforce much in each other's company in the house, and presently Catherine began to make it clear to her obstinate cousin that she wished to be friends.

into Occurrences 1%

She plunged with Catherine Earnshaw into the thick of the tumult, and her detachment is not more wonderful than her immersion.

Which preposition to use with  earnshaw