Which preposition to use with goatherds

in Occurrences 2%

Even the Italian peasant, who had been a goatherd in Calabria, and could hardly write his name, showed more delicacy, according to his lights, which were certainly not dazzling.

of Occurrences 1%

One of the goatherds of the same bucolic poet wishes he were a bee that he might fly to the grotto of Amaryllis.

with Occurrences 1%

Clarissa pelts her goatherd with apples, should he stray

Which preposition to use with  goatherds