Which preposition to use with punctual

to Occurrences 40%

Punctual to the hour she made her appearance, and croaked out, "My price is three hundred pieces of gold.

in Occurrences 23%

Yet I daresay the fellow is punctual in settling his milk-score, etc. Keep to your bank, and the bank will keep you.

as Occurrences 16%

"It is just their breakfast time, and they are as punctual as clockwork.

at Occurrences 12%

After a series of vain protests, and petulant warnings against her cousin by marriage, who she said was punctual at church, and learned, and knew statistics, but was "not for Conrad, no, no, no!"

for Occurrences 2%

When lagging members of Congress came in, as they often did, after the guests had sat down to dinner, the president's only apology was, 'Gentlemen (or sir) we are too punctual for you.

after Occurrences 1%

It is probable that he was more punctual after this.

with Occurrences 1%

Narcissus, who used to be so punctual with such a request.

Which preposition to use with  punctual