Which preposition to use with punctuated

with Occurrences 17%

It has been suggested that the passage be punctuated with a full stop at 'call.'

at Occurrences 5%

The two lived in a state of simmering hostility, punctuated at intervals by crises, which usually resulted in Lower Borlock having to play some unskilled laborer in place of their star batsman, employed doing "overtime.

in Occurrences 1%

Punctuated in all the music of fairy bands and the whirr of fairy machinery were the incessant voices of frogs.

throughout Occurrences 1%

His discourse was punctuated throughout with quiet laughter.

Which preposition to use with  punctuated