Which preposition to use with rarebits

after Occurrences 1%

It must be a sad thing not to be able to eat lobster and ice-cream together, and to have to say "No" to broiled mushrooms, and not to dare to eat Welsh-rarebits after the theatre, and to have to lock up your chafing-dish.

out Occurrences 1%

Mr. Fotheringay helped himself to a second Welsh rarebit out of vacancy, and took a mouthful.

with Occurrences 1%

Dwight Herbert savoured his rarebit with a great show of long wrinkled dimples.

Which preposition to use with  rarebits