Which preposition to use with reciprocate

by Occurrences 6%

Hence he was very popular among them, and they reciprocated by showing their appreciation in every possible way.

in Occurrences 4%

"Only a young, beautiful, and accomplished sister shared his splendid establishment in Malaga; and for her my father formed an engrossing attachment, reciprocated in the fullest, almost simultaneously with his friendship for her brother.

with Occurrences 4%

I passed along the pavement with it, until I met a street-sweeper, and there threw it upon his heap with a nod, which he reciprocated with a bow.

for Occurrences 1%

It has been said that he abused the confidence reposed in him by women; that he encouraged affection which he did not reciprocate for artistic purposes.

on Occurrences 1%

A liberal disposition toward this great national policy is manifested by most of the European States, and ought to be reciprocated on our part by giving the immigrants effective national protection.

to Occurrences 1%

More than forty years ago, on the 3d March, 1815, Congress passed an act offering to all nations to admit their vessels laden with their national productions into the ports of the United States upon the same terms with our own vessels provided they would reciprocate to us similar advantages.

Which preposition to use with  reciprocate