Which preposition to use with redundant

in Occurrences 8%

So perfect in form, so redundant in beauty, so delicate, so spotless, so fragrant,what presumptuous lover ever dared, in his most enamored hour, to liken his mistress to a water-lily?

with Occurrences 2%

There are the new Assize Courtsthe foundation-stone of which was laid by the Queen in 1887; they are built of brick and terra-cotta, redundant with detailed ornament, some of it perhaps of a too florid character.

to Occurrences 1%

Moreover, there are moral and physical obstacles which put difficulties in the way of the transfer of labour from places where it is redundant to those where it is wanting.

Which preposition to use with  redundant