Which preposition to use with shiverings

of Occurrences 9%

And there befell, that day, a mighty shivering of lances and many a knightly deed was wrought.

in Occurrences 2%

* I slept in a room on the second-floor of a Bloomsbury hotel that night; and waking the next day at ten, ate with accursed shiverings in the cold banqueting-room; went out then, and under drear low skies walked a long way to the West district, accompanied all the time by a sound of flapping flagsfluttering robes and ragsand grotesquely grim glimpses of decay.

at Occurrences 1%

You set your rich, warm and soft to the fore, and leave the poor shivering at the door.

through Occurrences 1%

I knew when the watcher was coming by tremors and shiverings through all my being; and no sensation so unsupportable has it ever been mine to bear.

with Occurrences 1%

He would lie awake shivering with terror.

Which preposition to use with  shiverings