Which preposition to use with enigmatic

as Occurrences 2%

Her essential infelicity was as profound and as enigmatic as ever.

about Occurrences 1%

There was a good deal that was enigmatic about her.

to Occurrences 1%

It happened that the very vividness of his impressions had often made him the more enigmatic to his friends, and had contributed to an apparent indefiniteness in his sentiments.

with Occurrences 1%

The pressure of a hand upon his own roused him to discover the Liane Delorme had seated herself beside him, in a chair that looked the other way, so that her face was not far from his; and he could scarcely be unaware of its hinted beauty, now wan and glimmering in starlight, enigmatic with soft, close shadows.

Which preposition to use with  enigmatic